D’Artagnan and his three companions get the title, but Milady de Winter runs away with The Three Musketeers. Branded, imprisoned, married and widowed under half a dozen names, she is a spy, a seductress, and — the detail that makes her modern — a woman who survives a world built entirely to punish women like her, by becoming better at its own games than the men who invented them.
Dumas gives her a fleur-de-lis branded on her shoulder, the mark of a criminal past she never fully explains, and lets the reader’s sympathy curdle and re-form across the novel: victim, then monster, then something the book never quite lets us settle on. She is the engine of the plot’s second half, and she is more interesting, chapter for chapter, than any of the men chasing her.
It’s the same trick Dumas plays with Edmond Dantès a few years later: a wronged figure who becomes formidable by refusing to stay wronged. Milady just does it without a fortune, an island, or the reader’s forgiveness.
Enjoyed this piece?
Get the next one — our essays on the classics and news of each new Erato Press edition — straight to your inbox.